Ketones vs Carbohydrates for Exercise

11/09/2024
Shaun Waso
Burn Fats | Get Into Ketosis

Introduction

When we think about fuelling our bodies for exercise, carbohydrates are often seen as the go-to energy source. They’re quick, accessible, and familiar. But what if there was a more efficient way to fuel your body, especially during prolonged or intense exercise? Enter ketones. Ketones are molecules produced from fat when carbohydrate levels are low, and they offer an alternative, steady energy source that may be more beneficial than carbs, particularly in challenging conditions like heat.

In this post, we’ll explore how ketones compare to carbohydrates, why they are considered a more efficient fuel source for athletes, and how they can help you maintain better performance when exercising. Whether you’re a seasoned athlete or just curious about how your body uses fuel, understanding the benefits of ketones can change the way you approach exercise. Let’s dive into why ketones could be the better fuel for your next workout.


Understanding Carbohydrates as a Fuel Source

Carbohydrates have long been regarded as the primary fuel source for athletes and those engaging in intense physical activity. When you consume carbohydrates, your body breaks them down into glucose, a simple sugar that your muscles use for quick energy. This process, known as glycolysis, provides a fast-acting source of energy, especially during high-intensity workouts or sprints. Your body also stores some of this glucose as glycogen in muscles and the liver, which can be accessed during exercise.

However, carbohydrate metabolism comes with its limitations. Glycogen stores are finite and can be depleted after about 90 minutes of continuous exercise. Once your glycogen reserves are exhausted, your energy levels can crash, leading to what athletes often refer to as “hitting the wall.” To compensate, the body shifts towards anaerobic metabolism, which produces energy less efficiently and creates byproducts like lactate. This lactate buildup contributes to muscle soreness and fatigue, limiting performance.

Additionally, carbohydrate metabolism generates more heat than fat or ketone metabolism. During intense exercise, particularly in hot conditions, the body struggles to dissipate this excess heat. This can exacerbate thermoregulatory stress, leading to a rise in core temperature and an increased risk of heat exhaustion. The more heat the body generates, the harder it is to cool down, making exercise feel even more difficult.

While carbohydrates provide a fast energy boost, the rapid fluctuations in energy levels, along with increased heat production and lactate buildup, can make them a less ideal fuel source for prolonged or intense activities—especially in challenging environments like hot or humid weather. This is where ketones present a significant advantage.


Introduction to Ketones

Ketones are an alternative fuel source for the body, produced when carbohydrates are in short supply. This happens naturally during fasting, low-carb diets, or prolonged exercise. When your body doesn’t have enough carbs to burn for energy, it turns to fat reserves, breaking them down into molecules called ketones. The primary ketones used for energy are beta-hydroxybutyrate (BHB), acetoacetate, and acetone.

Unlike carbohydrates, which require a complex digestion and absorption process, ketones are produced directly by the liver and enter the bloodstream, ready for use. They bypass the need for insulin to help them enter cells, allowing them to provide a faster, more reliable source of energy for both your muscles and brain.

One of the key advantages of ketones is that they offer a stable and sustained energy supply. Carbohydrates can lead to spikes and crashes in blood sugar levels, but ketones provide a steady flow of energy, preventing the fatigue and energy dips that many experience during exercise. This makes ketones especially useful for endurance activities, where consistent energy over long periods is crucial.

In addition to this stable energy, ketones help reduce muscle fatigue by producing less lactate than glucose does. Lactate build-up is a major factor in muscle soreness and fatigue during high-intensity exercise. By relying on ketones, athletes can perform longer with less muscle strain, making ketones a valuable tool for those pushing their physical limits.


The Thermoregulatory Advantage of Ketones

Thermoregulation is your body’s ability to maintain a stable internal temperature, even when faced with external heat or physical exertion. This is especially important during exercise, as the body generates heat through muscle activity, which it must dissipate to prevent overheating. In hot or humid environments, the challenge is even greater, as your body works harder to stay cool by increasing sweat production and redirecting blood flow to the skin. This can strain the cardiovascular system and lead to fatigue.

When your body relies on carbohydrates as a fuel source during exercise, it generates more heat than when it burns fat or ketones. Carbohydrate metabolism produces more byproducts, such as lactate, which contribute to this heat, worsening the strain on your body’s thermoregulatory systems. As your core temperature rises, your heart rate increases, and you begin to feel more fatigued, making it harder to sustain performance. This phenomenon is called thermoregulatory stress, and it can quickly lead to overheating, decreased endurance, and heat-related illnesses like heat exhaustion or heat stroke.

In contrast, ketone metabolism is much more thermally efficient. When your body uses ketones for energy, it produces less heat, easing the strain on your thermoregulatory system. This can help keep your core temperature lower during exercise, allowing you to maintain performance for longer, especially in hot conditions. By reducing the amount of heat generated during exercise, ketones allow your body to focus more on cooling itself effectively and less on managing excess heat produced by fuel metabolism.

Additionally, because ketones are a more efficient fuel source, they require less oxygen to produce energy compared to carbohydrates. This means that even when your body is under thermoregulatory stress, it can still supply energy to your muscles without demanding as much oxygen, reducing strain on your cardiovascular system. This efficiency helps delay fatigue, keeping your energy levels stable for longer and allowing you to push through high-intensity or prolonged exercise without overheating.

By producing less internal heat and providing a steady energy supply, ketones not only support better performance but also help reduce the risk of heat-related issues. Athletes who fuel with ketones may experience less muscle fatigue, lower perceived exertion, and greater endurance—making ketones an ideal choice for those training or competing in challenging environments where thermoregulation is critical.


The Efficiency of Ketones in Producing Energy

One of the biggest advantages ketones offer over carbohydrates is their superior energy efficiency. To understand this, it’s essential to look at how energy is produced in the body. Energy is measured in the form of adenosine triphosphate (ATP), which powers every muscle contraction and cellular process in your body. Both carbohydrates and ketones can produce ATP, but they do so in very different ways.

When your body uses carbohydrates for energy, it first breaks them down into glucose, which then goes through a series of processes—glycolysis and the Krebs cycle—to generate ATP. However, glucose metabolism is not the most efficient method. It requires more oxygen to produce energy and generates less ATP per unit of oxygen compared to ketones. This inefficiency is especially problematic during aerobic (oxygen-dependent) activities, where the body’s demand for oxygen is already high. The limited efficiency of carbohydrate metabolism can cause faster fatigue, especially during endurance activities or exercise in hot environments.

In contrast, ketones produce 20-30% more ATP per unit of oxygen than glucose, making them a far more efficient fuel source. This means that your body can generate more energy from ketones with less oxygen, which reduces cardiovascular strain during exercise. When oxygen is scarce or when your body is under stress from high temperatures or intense activity, ketones can provide a significant advantage by allowing your muscles to keep working efficiently without overwhelming your oxygen supply.

Another major benefit of ketones is that they produce less lactate compared to carbohydrates. Lactate is a byproduct of anaerobic metabolism, which builds up in the muscles during intense exercise and leads to soreness and fatigue. Because ketones generate less lactate, athletes who rely on them as a fuel source can experience less muscle fatigue and recover more quickly after workouts.

This energy efficiency also plays a crucial role in helping athletes maintain consistent performance during prolonged exercise. With carbohydrates, athletes may experience energy spikes followed by crashes as glycogen stores are depleted, leading to inconsistent energy levels. Ketones, on the other hand, provide a steady and continuous energy supply, drawn from fat reserves. This helps avoid the energy dips associated with carbohydrate depletion and allows athletes to maintain higher levels of endurance.

In summary, ketones not only provide a more stable and sustained energy source but also enable your body to produce more energy with less oxygen, reduce lactate buildup, and minimise muscle fatigue. This efficiency makes ketones an ideal fuel for endurance sports, particularly in conditions where oxygen availability is limited or where thermoregulation is a challenge, such as during long-distance events or exercising in the heat.


Benefits of Ketones in Endurance and Heat Stress

For athletes, especially those engaging in endurance activities, the ability to sustain energy and perform at a high level for extended periods is crucial. This becomes even more challenging when exercising in hot or humid conditions, where the body has to manage both energy production and thermoregulation simultaneously. In these situations, ketones provide unique benefits that can help athletes maintain performance while reducing the risks associated with heat stress.

Sustained Energy Supply

One of the major challenges athletes face during prolonged exercise is the depletion of glycogen stores, which can lead to sudden energy crashes. Ketones provide a continuous energy supply by drawing on fat reserves, which are far more abundant than the body’s limited glycogen stores. This steady flow of energy prevents the dips and spikes associated with carbohydrate metabolism

, allowing athletes to sustain their performance over long periods without feeling drained.

Because ketones bypass the digestive process and are readily available in the bloodstream, they offer a more immediate source of energy during prolonged physical activity. This can be especially helpful in endurance sports like marathons, triathlons, or long-distance cycling, where maintaining energy levels is key to performance.

Reduced Perceived Exertion (RPE)

Perceived exertion, or how hard exercise feels, plays a big role in determining how long an athlete can sustain physical activity. When the body is under stress from heat or fatigue, perceived exertion increases, making the effort feel much harder than it actually is. Studies suggest that fuelling with ketones can lower the rate of perceived exertion (RPE), meaning that athletes may feel less fatigued while performing the same level of physical effort.

By reducing the sensation of exertion, ketones allow athletes to push through mental and physical barriers more easily, enabling them to maintain higher levels of performance for longer periods. This reduction in perceived effort can be especially important when exercising in hot conditions, where heat stress can make every movement feel more taxing.

Improved Thermoregulation

In hot environments, the body faces the dual challenge of producing energy while dissipating heat. When athletes rely on carbohydrates for energy, the process of metabolising glucose generates more internal heat, which adds to the strain on the body’s thermoregulatory system. Ketones, on the other hand, produce less heat during metabolism, helping to keep the core temperature lower during exercise. This reduced heat production allows athletes to perform in hot conditions without their bodies overheating as quickly.

Additionally, the efficiency of ketones in producing energy with less oxygen can help reduce cardiovascular strain during exercise. By requiring less oxygen to produce energy, ketones free up more resources for cooling the body, allowing athletes to focus on performance rather than battling both heat and oxygen demands.

Faster Recovery and Muscle Protection

Ketones also offer protective benefits for the muscles, thanks to their anti-inflammatory properties. During intense or prolonged exercise, muscles are subjected to inflammation and oxidative stress, which can lead to soreness and longer recovery times. Ketones help reduce inflammation and oxidative stress, which not only minimizes muscle soreness but also supports quicker recovery between workouts. This can be particularly advantageous for endurance athletes who have to train and compete frequently.

Because ketones produce less lactate than carbohydrates, they reduce the buildup of this fatigue-causing byproduct in the muscles. This means athletes are less likely to experience the heavy, sore feeling in their muscles during or after exercise, allowing them to continue training at a high intensity without being hindered by muscle fatigue.

Enhanced Endurance in Heat

For athletes who train or compete in hot and humid conditions, ketones offer an edge by helping to lower core temperature, reduce perceived exertion, and provide a steady energy supply. These factors allow athletes to perform longer and at a higher level than they could when relying on carbohydrates alone. Additionally, the risk of heat-related illnesses, such as heat exhaustion or heat stroke, is reduced when the body generates less internal heat from its fuel source.

By fueling with ketones, athletes can manage the dual demands of energy production and thermoregulation more effectively, enabling them to maintain endurance and prevent the debilitating effects of heat stress during prolonged exercise.


Why Athletes Should Consider Ketones

For athletes aiming to optimize performance, endurance, and recovery, especially in challenging conditions, ketones offer a range of benefits that make them an ideal fuel source. Here’s why athletes should seriously consider incorporating ketones into their nutrition strategy:

1. More Efficient Energy Production

Ketones produce 20-30% more energy (ATP) per unit of oxygen than glucose, making them a highly efficient fuel source. This means athletes can sustain their energy levels for longer with less oxygen demand, reducing cardiovascular strain during exercise. For endurance athletes, this efficiency allows them to maintain performance over extended periods without the energy crashes often associated with carbohydrates.

2. Reduced Fatigue and Faster Recovery

Because ketones produce less lactate than carbohydrates, they reduce the buildup of this fatigue-causing byproduct in the muscles. Less lactate means less muscle soreness and fatigue during exercise, allowing athletes to push harder for longer. Additionally, ketones’ anti-inflammatory properties help speed up recovery by reducing muscle damage and oxidative stress, enabling athletes to train more consistently without prolonged recovery periods.

3. Improved Thermoregulation in Hot Conditions

Ketone metabolism generates less heat compared to carbohydrate metabolism, which helps keep the body’s core temperature lower during exercise. This is especially beneficial for athletes competing in hot or humid environments, where overheating can lead to early fatigue, heat exhaustion, or even heat stroke. By producing less internal heat, ketones enable athletes to manage thermoregulatory stress more effectively, improving endurance in tough conditions.

4. Stable, Sustained Energy

One of the most significant advantages of ketones is the steady and continuous energy supply they provide. Unlike carbohydrates, which can cause spikes and dips in blood sugar, ketones offer a more reliable source of energy. This prevents energy crashes and ensures that athletes have a consistent fuel source throughout prolonged activities. Whether running a marathon or competing in a triathlon, ketones help maintain energy levels, allowing athletes to perform at their peak for longer.

5. Lower Perceived Exertion

Athletes fueled by ketones often experience a lower rate of perceived exertion (RPE), meaning that physical effort feels easier even during intense exercise. This reduction in perceived effort enables athletes to maintain high levels of performance without feeling as fatigued. For endurance athletes, particularly in hot conditions, this can be a game-changer, allowing them to push through mental and physical barriers that would otherwise limit performance.

6. Practical Integration of Ketones

Incorporating ketones into an athlete’s diet can be done through several methods. The most common approach is adopting a ketogenic diet, which promotes the natural production of ketones by lowering carbohydrate intake and increasing fat consumption. Another option is fasting before exercise, which triggers the body’s natural ketone production. For those who prefer a more direct route, exogenous ketone supplements are also available, allowing athletes to boost ketone levels quickly without altering their diet.


Conclusion: A Smarter Fuel for Athletes

For athletes looking to enhance endurance, manage thermoregulation, and recover faster, ketones present a powerful alternative to traditional carbohydrate-based fuelling strategies. With their ability to provide a stable, efficient, and heat-friendly energy source, ketones are a smart choice for athletes who want to maximize their performance in any condition—especially in the heat. Whether through diet or supplementation, incorporating ketones into your training regimen can give you the competitive edge to go further and perform better.


Dive deeper into our latest Articles

Keto Diet Sustainability

Keto Diet Sustainability

Embarking on a keto diet can be a transformative journey, offering numerous health benefits and a potential pathway to sustainable weight management. However, the key...

read more